top of page

2026 Judicial Voter Guide: Iowa Court of Appeals

Writer: Victoria Henderson Weber
Victoria Henderson Weber
Oct 9
4 min read

Updated: Nov 11

Election: November 3, 2026 | NAACP Des Moines | Live. Work. Thrive.: Justice Prevails

This nonpartisan guide explains judges on the 2026 Polk County ballot. It presents professional background, the Iowa State Bar Association’s *2026 Judicial Performance Review* as reported by a public voter guide, and directions to official judicial records and independent case-search tools. We make no retention recommendation and no ranking of judges.

Understanding the survey

The bar association surveyed Iowa attorneys familiar with judges’ work. The retention percentage reports the share of respondents who answered that the judge should be retained; it is not an NAACP recommendation or a measure of all voters’ opinions. Category ratings are separate average responses on a five-point scale. Numbers of respondents differ across judges, and lawyer feedback is not an independent finding about any particular decision or person.

What the Court of Appeals does

Iowa’s intermediate appellate court reviews legal issues in appeals transferred by the Iowa Supreme Court. It generally decides cases in panels of three judges, not by holding new trials. The published opinion is the decision of the panel’s majority. A named opinion author does not mean every other judge disagreed or that the opinion reflects the author’s personal preferences. Judges may also join other opinions, concur, or dissent.

All three Court of Appeals judges listed below stand for retention statewide in 2026.

John M. Sandy

Court: Court of Appeals. Professional background: Appointed to the Court of Appeals in 2024 after serving as a district court judge beginning in 2021. Previously managing partner of Sandy Law Firm and worked in public defense.

Attorney performance survey

Attorney survey (2026): 87.8% indicated support for retention; 197 attorneys responding to that judge's evaluation. The following are individual survey items, each on a 1–5 scale, not a combined score:

• Knowledge/application of the law: 4.2/5

• Temperament and demeanor: 4.2/5

• Perceived equal treatment, including implicit-bias awareness: 4.4/5

• Deciding cases based on law and fact, free of outside influence: 4.2/5

Other published category averages: written-opinion clarity 4.2/5; promptness of decisions 4.3/5.

Where to research this judge's decisions

Review the official court records linked in the resources section below. The optional independent index provides a starting point for finding cases; verify information against the original court opinion or case docket. No rulings have been selected or evaluated by the NAACP.

Optional LegisHawk case index (independent, not an official court source): https://legishawk.app/ia/judges/coa-sandy

Julie A. Schumacher

Court: Court of Appeals. Professional background: Appointed to the Court of Appeals in 2019, after serving as a district court and district associate judge. Her previous career included nearly two decades in private practice in Denison.

Attorney performance survey

Attorney survey (2026): 92.7% indicated support for retention; 178 attorneys responding to that judge's evaluation. The following are individual survey items, each on a 1–5 scale, not a combined score:

• Knowledge/application of the law: 4.3/5

• Temperament and demeanor: 4.5/5

• Perceived equal treatment, including implicit-bias awareness: 4.5/5

• Deciding cases based on law and fact, free of outside influence: 4.4/5

Other published category averages: written-opinion clarity 4.3/5; promptness of decisions 4.5/5.

Where to research this judge's decisions

Review the official court records linked in the resources section below. The optional independent index provides a starting point for finding cases; verify information against the original court opinion or case docket. No rulings have been selected or evaluated by the NAACP.

Optional LegisHawk case index (independent, not an official court source): https://legishawk.app/ia/judges/coa-schumacher

Sharon Soorholtz Greer

Court: Court of Appeals. Professional background: Appointed to the Court of Appeals in 2019 after private law practice in Marshalltown. Her professional service includes Iowa court rules and children’s justice work.

Attorney performance survey

Attorney survey (2026): 90.9% indicated support for retention; 230 attorneys responding to that judge's evaluation. The following are individual survey items, each on a 1–5 scale, not a combined score:

• Knowledge/application of the law: 4.5/5

• Temperament and demeanor: 4.5/5

• Perceived equal treatment, including implicit-bias awareness: 4.6/5

• Deciding cases based on law and fact, free of outside influence: 4.4/5

Other published category averages: written-opinion clarity 4.4/5; promptness of decisions 4.5/5.

Where to research this judge's decisions

Review the official court records linked in the resources section below. The optional independent index provides a starting point for finding cases; verify information against the original court opinion or case docket. No rulings have been selected or evaluated by the NAACP.

Optional LegisHawk case index (independent, not an official court source): https://legishawk.app/ia/judges/coa-greer

Original sources and further reading

• 2026 ISBA evaluation data, reproduced with named judges and question-level detail — https://iavoterguide.org/judicial-retention

• Iowa Judicial Nominating Commission: why appellate reversals alone cannot determine a judge's quality — https://www.iowajnc.gov/judicial-retention-elections/what-about-decisions-reversed-by-a-higher-court/

• Iowa Judicial Branch: court assignment and jurisdiction — https://www.iowacourts.gov/iowa-courts/district-court/how-judges-are-assigned-to-new-cases

Where to find judicial opinions and court records

Iowa's appellate opinions are publicly available, but trial-court rulings are not collected in one complete public online archive. Iowa Courts Online shows public dockets but not necessarily the actual documents; for a trial-court ruling, contact the clerk of court in the county where the case was filed. Confidential cases may not be accessible.

• Iowa Judicial Branch: appellate opinions (official) — https://www.iowacourts.gov/iowa-courts/court-of-appeals/court-of-appeals-court-opinions/

• Iowa Courts Online: public case dockets (official) — https://www.iowacourts.state.ia.us/ESAWebApp/

• Iowa Judicial Nominating Commission: how to find rulings (official) — https://www.iowajnc.gov/judicial-retention-elections/how-do-i-find-a-judges-decisions-or-rulings

• Iowa Judicial Branch: judicial retention and ISBA evaluations (official) — https://www.iowacourts.gov/for-the-public/educational-resources-and-services/judicial-selection-and-retention

• LegisHawk: how to read a judge record (independent; AI-assisted analysis) — https://legishawk.app/ia/judges/guide/

• Justia: Iowa Court of Appeals opinions, 2026 (third-party republication) — https://law.justia.com/cases/iowa/court-of-appeals/2026/

LegisHawk and Justia are third-party discovery tools, not official court records. LegisHawk includes some AI-assisted classification and summaries. The selection of cases in a searchable index is not a complete account of a judge's work; an appellate reversal or affirmance alone does not establish judicial quality.

• Original Iowa State Bar Association 2026 Judicial Performance Review (official report access): https://www.iowabar.org/?pg=JudicialEvaluations

Research and editorial note

This is a nonpartisan NAACP Des Moines voter-education resource. It does not endorse, oppose, rank, grade, or recommend retention or removal of any judge. All reported scores come from the Iowa State Bar Association's survey of attorneys, as reproduced in public election research. The original ISBA report is linked for direct review. No individual judicial rulings have been selected or evaluated by the branch. Research review updated: November 1, 2026.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page